THE 15 BEST Restaurants in Baldwinsville, NY - With Menus, Reviews, Photos - Updated June 2024 (2024)

Customers` Favorites

“Cannot recommend Angry Garlic enough. They have been one of our staple places to get a good meal for a while. This weekend was our first time going with a big group of people. We had a party of 15. Service was OUTSTANDING. Nick was our server and he was the absolute best. We never had to ask for a water refill, he was tentative, and he laughed and joked with us. The food was quick to come out of the kitchen (especially for a large party). The food was delicious. Everyone left full and satisfied. Cannot recommend this restaurant enough!”

Customers` Favorites

“Best pizza in Baldwinsville! Best dough ever!”

Customers` Favorites

“Such a cute and cozy restaurant and shop! Very friendly service and delicious food. The orzo is a must!”

Customers` Favorites

“Great coffee,atmosphere and service”

Customers` Favorites

“Fantastic restaurant with delicious Indian cuisine and great service.”

Customers` Favorites

“Persimmons knocked it out of the park again! New menu items were a huge hit! Entertainment made for a great atmosphere! Love Tuesday nights Jazz series !”

Customers` Favorites

“Stopped in to BG1 on Friday. Such a cute place. Our server/bartender was Ricky (I believe). The drinks were amazing and the food was out of this world. We had the trio of dips with pita chips (still in aww and my boss id trying to figure out how to make the artichoke dip). I had the chicken tortilla and she had the berry salad. We will definitely be back!”

Customers` Favorites

“Dined here last evening. The warm brie appetizer was very good and a nice change from ordinary appetizers. The steak was very tender and cooked to perfection. For dessert I had the chocolate torte which came with raspberry sauce. The combination of the chocolate and raspberry....yum! The staff were all nice, friendly, and informative. I'll definitely be back!”

Customers` Favorites

“My favorite place when I come home see my dad great food service and people ! One of the best in the US !”

Customers` Favorites

“So happy Atlantic Seafood is in Baldwinsville. I have tried haddock everywhere. This place makes the flakest, best battered, perfectly cooked haddock everytime. The staff are very friendly and quick.”

Customers` Favorites

“Excellent not to be taken as just a breakfast place, healthy salads, good lunches and Friday dinners”

Customers` Favorites

“The food was so good, modestly priced and generous portions. It's worth every dime. The staff are very friendly too. By far the best Mexican food we have around here.”

Customers` Favorites

“Good food and friendly staff”

“Delicious beers. Always!!”

Customers` Favorites

“idk why everyone is giving bad reviews. this place is awsome food is good people get that golden fork out of your back end and eat some good bbq. the brisket always perfectly smoked, the bacon pulled pork is to die for, and who dosent love amazing smoked wings. I mean come on people this place is a no brainer for lunch dinner and even entertainment at the bar.”

“I’m picky about my coffee and Shamballa is absolutely awesome. Just ordered a mocha and it is perfect. This is probably the best mocha I’ve ever tasted. It’s got to be the beans as Emmitt, the owner of Shamballa Café and Coffee Roasters, roasts and grinds the beans himself. I usually go to a large chain coffee place, but I definitely won’t when I’m here in Baldwinsville. Shamballa is simply amazing.”

“There are some areas where this place gets 5 stars. The ambiance, music, and other activities to do make me want to give it 5 stars. I always have fun when a good band comes to town. The food didn't blow me away but it was good. Drinks are good and cheap but sometimes can take a while to get. Parking can be hectic on busy nights. Overall very cool bar with a beach dancefloor.”

Customers` Favorites

“We went during B'ville dining week. Started with a tasty New England clam chowder and salad. On to an appetizer of Pot Stickers that was better than most Asian restaurants. Dinner was two different versions of their Ricotta Gnocchi. Soft pillows of love they were. I also enjoyed a smoked bourbon that is always a treat. If you enjoy great food Mohegan Manor is the place!”

Customers` Favorites

“Delicious food, great family!!! had our business for decades!”

“Absolutely amazing staff both in the kitchen and the bar. Genuine owners, amazing food, and a great atmosphere.”

Customers` Favorites

“I've enjoyed the food here, but the sitting areas are not cozy. The last thing I want to do is look at people's rear ends while I'm eating because they're picking up or waiting for their order. Would be nice if it was all separate.Parking: Pot holes.”

“great Beer, Great Bartenders, Great music. friendly and home like Atmosphere”

Customers` Favorites

“I had Pasta’s cater a luncheon for my son’s graduation from the police academy and the food was absolutely delicious…. The chicken parm was amazing. I will definitely order from them again! Thank you!”

Customers` Favorites

“Jessica is amazing! Incredibly accommodating. She even met me at the bakery early so I could pick up cupcakes for Teacher Appreciation week so they would be as fresh as possible. Highly Recommend!!!”

Customers` Favorites

“Absolutely amazing staff both in the kitchen and the bar. Genuine owners, amazing food, and a great atmosphere.”

Customers` Favorites

“Th we food is excellent in my opinion anyway. Everything I've had there's always been excellent and packed so it stays hot until I get home.The 4 stars for service is because they only ever give you one fortune cookie with an entree. So we have to split it. Probably foolish of me, but just seems a tad cheap.Like most take-out Chinese restaurants, it really doesn't have much atmosphere.”

“The owner is absolutely AMAZING! She truly goes above and beyond and for that I am very appreciative!! Love their teas, shakes, and protein balls! ❤️”

Customers` Favorites

“Not your ordinary bar food. Simple yet creative menu, great selection of craft beers on tap. When the weather gets warmer has some nice outdoor seating available. Can spend 30 minutes for a quick meal and drink or just relax for a couple hours.”

Customers` Favorites

“Brittany was such a great server! She ran like crazy and was on point with everything! They were packed and under staffed. The meal was wonderful and we had a great time!!”

Customers` Favorites

“Best Authentic Mexican Restaurant in the Syracuse area! Great family atmosphere, fun, and festive! Staff is super friendly and attentive! Ten out of ten! Highly recommend!”

Customers` Favorites

“Super busy on the Saturday before Mothera Day Sunday. We were still sat within 6 minutes. We got a pop, a hot chocolate, and 2 hot sandwiches with fries. Everything was a great portion, well proced and the servers were all very attentive and worked well together. Great experience, always.”

Customers` Favorites

“We ordered all the food for our wedding from Sals. That was last September, we are still getting great comments.They even made Italian wedding soup for us.(not on the menu) it was amazing. it was there on time, hot and ready. we could not have been more pleased with all the dishes. I highly recommend!!”

Customers` Favorites

“Had a great visit. My grandson asked to go to Dunkin before school on his birthday. The lady working the counter was so very kind and wished him a happy birthday.”

Customers` Favorites

“We had a surprise bday dinner for my Husbands 60th Friday night. We had great service, friendly staff and delicious food. They came out after everyone was finished eating and surprised him with a chocolate lava bday cake. Totally unexpected. We had a great time. Definitely going back in the future.”

Customers` Favorites

“I visit this Dunkin' location once or twice a week and I have been doing so for years. I also travel a lot and frequent many other Dunkin locations all over NY State. The Baldwinsville Dunkin on Genesse St. (and its professional staff) can best be described by one word, EXCEPTIONAL! The staff is always fast and friendly and at the times they are short staffed (or really busy) they always apologize for the delay. I believe there are two reasons for this exceptionalism. The "prep" people and the Manager Jeremy.Jessica and Theresa are just unbelievable at their jobs. When they are preparing the food, it is so fast. It's as though they are doing a dance, never missing a beat and maintaining a rhythm of incredible speed. Jess is lightning fast and at times, you will literally see her dancing at the ovens. (It's also come to my attention that this young lady drives a long distance to the job she clearly loves. This is so rare for a young person today) Theresa is not only fast, she is methodical! She is like the North Star of the Dunkin universe. Always there and always constant. She is a true master of her craft. I am so grateful that these two ladies chose my local Dunkin to share their talents as with their abilities they could succeed at any other Jobs/careers they wanted.You have to tip your hat to the Manager, Jeremy as this consistent high quality of service comes from the top down. He is almost always there, with his sleeves rolled up working along side his crew members. He is leading by example and nurturing is young people continually. He is amazing! (and truly a nice guy) Dunkin on Genesse St in Baldwinsville is exceptional!!!!”