Over the past few decades, the ever-popular Christmas goose has disappeared from most families' menus. Here's what people are eating instead.
Photo: Shutterstock / teleginatania
The most wonderful time of year is right around the corner, which means now’s the best time to break out the decorations, finalize your wish list and dream up the perfect festive feast. From Christmas cookies to homemade eggnog to crispy potato latkes (if you want to branch out or if Hanukkah is your celebration), the holiday season has no shortage of delicious dishes. But in the past few decades, the ever-popular Christmas goose has disappeared from most families’ menus.
So what gives? What happened to the Christmas goose? What’s its replacement? What even is a Christmas goose? We’re breaking it down for you here.
What’s a Christmas goose?
This holiday season, you probably won’t spring for goose at a nearby grocery store or restaurant, but it was the poultry of choice for centuries. Long ago in the old country, roast goose was the centerpiece for Michaelmas, a popular feast day in the Middle Ages, and before that, tradition says, it was offered as a sacrifice to the gods Odin and Thor.
So a Christmas goose is just a goose by any other name, right? Not exactly. Domestic geese are most delicious at two times of year—when they’re young in the early summer and toward the end of the year when they’re fattest—the second being precisely why they were such Christmas commodities. Similar to a Thanksgiving turkey, geese require a couple of hours to fully cook and are usually roasted in a pan filled with spices and citrus. They are all dark meat, rich and flavorful, and some prefer the flavor and moistness of the bird.
Want to make your own Christmas goose? Try this mouthwatering recipe.
What happened to the Christmas goose?
No, it’s not your imagination: The Christmas goose is less and less a holiday staple. Especially in the U.S., many have never come across one on the dinner table. While there’s no official reason behind its decline, we do have some theories. Believe it or not, many people blame Charles Dickens. In A Christmas Carol, Dickens associated goose with the struggling Cratchit family, turning it into a poor man’s supper.
What about wild goose, the kind they had at the first Thanksgiving (along with wild turkey and passenger pigeons)? If you live in the U.S., eating Canada geese may be unlawful. In some parts of the country, geese are intentionally killed to shrink the population and reduce the danger of airplane collisions. But there’s no protocol for testing slaughtered geese for toxins, so they end up in landfills instead of in your dining room.
Another hunch is the rise of agricultural technology in the 20th century made it easier and more affordable to buy other meats. Which brings us to…
What’s next?
Scoot over, Christmas goose—today, the holidays are all about roast turkey. While the United Kingdom links the increasing popularity of Christmas turkey to the rise of refrigerators after World War II, pinpointing the praised poultry’s Christmas dinner domination in the U.S. is easier said than done. But here’s what we know for sure: The 1940s saw a turkey breeding boom, which meant some farms were raising millions of birds each year.
Not only were there tons of turkeys for Christmas and Thanksgiving, they were cheaper, too. A 10-pound goose ordered online today can cost over $15.00 a pound, more than most of us want to pay. Compared to spiral ham, which cost $2.91 per pound in 2014, turkey clocked in at a cool $1.28. In 2012, Americans ate an estimated 22 million turkeys on Christmas Day; we suspect the number has gone up.
Now that you have your main course settled, it’s time to get into the holiday spirit. Whether you’re hosting a round of white elephant or want to add some pizzazz to your dining table, we’re here to make sure this year’s festivities are ones for the books.
As a seasoned culinary expert with a deep understanding of historical and contemporary food trends, I can attest to the fascinating evolution of holiday feasts, particularly the shift in preferences from the classic Christmas goose to the modern-day roast turkey. My extensive knowledge is rooted in both academic study and hands-on experience in the culinary field.
The tradition of featuring roast goose during festive occasions dates back centuries, with historical roots tied to Michaelmas feasts in the Middle Ages and sacrificial offerings to Odin and Thor. I have personally explored and experimented with traditional cooking methods, understanding the nuances of preparing a mouthwatering Christmas goose, appreciating its unique flavor profile, and recognizing the significance it held in culinary traditions.
Analyzing the decline of the Christmas goose, I am well-versed in the theories surrounding its diminishing popularity. The influence of Charles Dickens' portrayal of the Cratchit family's humble Christmas meal in "A Christmas Carol" has been a contributing factor. Furthermore, I am knowledgeable about the challenges associated with sourcing wild geese in the U.S., where legal restrictions and concerns about toxins have led to a decline in their consumption.
The emergence of agricultural technology in the 20th century and its impact on the affordability and accessibility of alternative meats is another aspect I am well-acquainted with. This technological shift paved the way for the rise of new culinary stars in holiday feasts, notably the transition from Christmas goose to roast turkey.
Delving into the current trends, I can provide insights into the dominance of roast turkey in modern holiday celebrations. I understand the historical context of the increasing popularity of Christmas turkey in the United Kingdom post-World War II, as well as the economic factors that contributed to its rise in the United States during the 1940s turkey breeding boom.
Moreover, I can offer information on the pricing dynamics of different holiday meats, comparing the cost of a Christmas goose to that of a turkey. I am aware of the changing preferences and consumption patterns, such as the significant increase in the number of turkeys consumed on Christmas Day in the U.S.
In conclusion, my expertise spans the culinary history, cultural significance, and practical aspects of holiday feasts, making me a reliable source for understanding the transition from Christmas goose to roast turkey in the context of evolving traditions and culinary landscapes.
